---
title: "Impact of large language model (ChatGPT) in healthcare: an umbrella review and evidence synthesis"
title_zh: "大语言模型对医疗意味着什么"
source: "Journal of Biomedical Science（PMC 全文，开放获取）"
author: "Usman Iqbal, Afifa Tanweer, Annisa Ristya Rahmanti, et al."
date: 2025-05-07
url: "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12057020/"
type: 期刊摘要与引言
level: 四六级+
word_count: 1107
tags:
  - 英语阅读/科技与人工智能
  - 主题/人工智能
  - 主题/医疗AI
  - 来源/PMC
  - 体裁/期刊摘要与引言
reading_time: 6
related:
  - "[[01-01-算法单一化对招聘的影响]]"
  - "[[01-02-人工智能风险管理框架]]"
  - "[[01-03-人工智能规模扩张之路]]"
---

# Impact of large language model (ChatGPT) in healthcare: an umbrella review and evidence synthesis

> [!note] 本篇导读
> 这是一篇发表在《Journal of Biomedical Science》上的"伞形综述"（umbrella review），把 17 篇关于 ChatGPT 进入医疗领域的系统综述又汇总了一遍。它既列出好处（辅助诊断、病历文书、医学教育），也把风险摆到台面上（隐私、算法偏见、内容准确性、问责空白）。
> 文体是标准的医学论文：摘要分三段，正文按 Background—Methods—Results 推进。句子偏长、名词化结构多，是练习"读学术摘要体"的好材料。文中的方括号数字是原文的文献编号，保留原样。

## 一、英文正文

### Abstract

#### Background

The emergence of Artificial Intelligence (AI), particularly Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (ChatGPT), a Large Language Model (LLM), in healthcare promises to reshape patient care, clinical decision-making, and medical education. This review aims to synthesise research findings to consolidate the implications of ChatGPT integration in healthcare and identify research gaps.

#### Main body

The umbrella review was conducted following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. The Cochrane Library, PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar were searched from inception until February 2024. Due to the heterogeneity of the included studies, no quantitative analysis was performed. Instead, information was extracted, summarised, synthesised, and presented in a narrative form. Two reviewers undertook title, abstract, and full text screening independently. The methodological quality and overall rating of the included reviews were assessed using A Measurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews (AMSTAR-2) checklist. The review examined 17 studies, comprising 15 systematic reviews and 2 meta-analyses, on ChatGPT in healthcare, revealing diverse focuses. The AMSTAR-2 assessment identified 5 moderate and 12 low-quality reviews, with deficiencies like study design justification and funding source reporting. The most reported theme that emerged was ChatGPT's use in disease diagnosis or clinical decision-making. While 82.4% of studies focused on its general usage, 17.6% explored unique topics like its role in medical examinations and conducting systematic reviews. Among these, 52.9% targeted general healthcare, with 41.2% focusing on specific domains like radiology, neurosurgery, gastroenterology, public health dentistry, and ophthalmology. ChatGPT’s use for manuscript review or writing was mentioned in 17.6% of reviews. Promising applications include enhancing patient care and clinical decision-making, though ethical, legal, and accuracy concerns require cautious integration.

#### Conclusion

We summarise the identified areas in reviews regarding ChatGPT's transformative impact in healthcare, highlighting patient care, decision-making, and medical education. Emphasising the importance of ethical regulations and the involvement of policymakers, we urge further investigation to ensure the reliability of ChatGPT and to promote trust in healthcare and research.

### Background

Recent advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) have brought transformative changes across various industries, including healthcare [16]. AI-powered tools and technologies offer the potential to revolutionise healthcare delivery, improving patient outcomes, and enhancing clinical decision-making processes. Among these technologies, ChatGPT (Chat Generative Pre-trained Transformer), a Large Language Model (LLM), developed by OpenAI, has received significant attention within the healthcare sector [12]. As a state-of-the-art Natural Language Processing (NLP) model trained on a vast corpus of text data, ChatGPT can generate human-like responses to text inputs. Operating on deep learning principles and employing a transformer architecture, ChatGPT surpasses traditional rule-based chatbots by not relying on predefined rules or templates for generating responses [23]. Instead, it leverages its extensive pre-trained knowledge to understand and respond to queries in a contextually relevant manner.

ChatGPT is a promising tool for a wide range of diverse and multifaceted applications in consumer health [23]. One of the primary areas of promise is in healthcare education. With its ability to generate informative and educational content, ChatGPT can serve as a valuable resource for medical students, healthcare professionals, and educators [25]. It can assist in the creation of educational materials, answer clinical queries, and facilitate interactive learning experiences. Additionally, ChatGPT can aid medical research by generating human-like text, offering fundamental guidance, and elucidating complex concepts [1]. In clinical practice, ChatGPT has the potential to streamline clinical documentation, patient communication, and decision support tasks, thus improving the workflow efficiency. By automating routine administrative tasks and providing real-time assistance, ChatGPT can help reduce the burden on healthcare professionals and enhance the quality of patient care [14]. Moreover, ChatGPT holds promise in diagnostic assistance and decision support. Its ability to process and analyze medical data, including patient histories, symptoms, and diagnostic tests, enables it to provide valuable insights and recommendations to healthcare providers. In fields such as radiology and pathology, ChatGPT can assist in image interpretation, differential diagnosis, and treatment planning, potentially improving diagnostic accuracy and patient outcomes [21]. Furthermore, it can offer second opinions on dermatological treatments, which may become increasingly reliable as it continues to optimize [33].

Despite its potential benefits, integrating ChatGPT into healthcare practice poses risks, challenges and limitations. Addressing risks associated with ethical concerns regarding patient privacy, data security, and algorithmic bias is crucial for ensuring its safe and responsible use. Moreover, verifying the accuracy, reliability, and trustworthiness of ChatGPT-generated content requires further investigation [34].

Translating promises into reality is always a significant step. The potential uses and benefits of ChatGPT for consumer health have emerged but are not yet fully realised. Further work is necessary to understand for what and how ChatGPT is being used. Similarly, understanding the risks, challenges and limitations of ChatGPT in consumer health can help ensure its appropriate and effective use. Given these considerations, conducting an umbrella review of systematic reviews on ChatGPT in consumer health is imperative. This study aims to provide a comprehensive overview through synthesis and evaluation, including evidence gap synthesis, discerns implications for integration, and highlight areas for further research and development.

### Methods

An umbrella review synthesises existing systematic reviews and meta-analyses on a topic, offering a comprehensive overview of evidence from multiple studies. It provides a broader perspective, enhancing research depth and reliability. Thus, it is ideal for exploring ChatGPT’s applications and impacts in healthcare. This umbrella review was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis Protocols guidelines (PRISMA) [26]. The checklist recommended by Choi et al. [8] was followed for conducting and reporting this umbrella review. The protocol was registered with the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) under registration number CRD42024510926.

#### Search strategy and eligibility criteria

The search strategy for included reviews was conducted across five electronic databases: (i) Cochrane Library (the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews); (ii) PubMed; (iii) Web of Science (all databases); (iv) Scopus; and (v) Google Scholar. The review period was up until February 3, 2024, without restrictions on language or publication year.

To capture a wide-ranging collection of reviews covering ChatGPT’s role in consumer health, we performed a comprehensive searching strategy across the database by using a combination of keywords and Boolean operators. For Google Scholar, specific filters for 'review articles' and sorting by relevance were applied, followed by a targeted search query to refine the results further.

[...]

### Results

The methodological quality assessment using AMSTAR-2, as summarised in Table 1, indicated that 5 out of 17 reviews (29.4%) were of moderate quality, while the remaining 12 out of 17 reviews (70.6%) had low quality. Notably, the most frequently lacking quality indicator was the explanation or justification of the selection of study designs for inclusion in the review (item number 3). Furthermore, deficiencies were observed in reporting the sources of funding (item number 10), addressing the risk of bias when discussing results (item number 13), and explaining or discussing observed heterogeneity (item number 14), indicating areas needing improvement in future reviews.

---

## 二、生词与短语精讲

> [!tip] 用法
> 先通读正文，再回来核对。建议先遮住中文释义自测。

| 单词/短语 | 音标 | 词性 | 英文释义 | 中文释义 | 文中例句 |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| transformative | /trænsˈfɔːmətɪv/ | adj. | causing a complete and important change | 带来变革的 | We summarise the identified areas in reviews regarding ChatGPT's transformative impact in healthcare, highlighting patient care, decision-making, and medical education. ... |
| revolutionise | /ˌrevəˈluːʃənaɪz/ | v. | to change something completely and fundamentally | 彻底改变 | AI-powered tools and technologies offer the potential to revolutionise healthcare delivery, improving patient outcomes, and enhancing clinical decision-making processes. |
| clinical | /ˈklɪnɪkl/ | adj. | relating to the treatment of patients | 临床的 | ChatGPT has the potential to streamline clinical documentation, patient communication, and decision support tasks, thus improving the workflow efficiency. ... |
| corpus | /ˈkɔːpəs/ | n. | a large collection of written or spoken texts | 语料库 | As a state-of-the-art Natural Language Processing (NLP) model trained on a vast corpus of text data, ChatGPT can generate human-like responses to text inputs. |
| architecture | /ˈɑːkɪtektʃə(r)/ | n. | the overall structure or design of a system | 架构 | Operating on deep learning principles and employing a transformer architecture, ChatGPT surpasses traditional rule-based chatbots by not relying on predefined rules or templates for generating responses [23]. |
| surpass | /səˈpɑːs/ | v. | to be better or greater than something else | 超越、胜过 | ChatGPT surpasses traditional rule-based chatbots by not relying on predefined rules or templates for generating responses [23]. ... |
| predefined | /ˌpriːdɪˈfaɪnd/ | adj. | decided or set in advance | 预先设定的 | ChatGPT surpasses traditional rule-based chatbots by not relying on predefined rules or templates for generating responses [23]. ... |
| leverage | /ˈliːvərɪdʒ/ | v. | to make use of something to achieve a result | 利用、凭借 | Instead, it leverages its extensive pre-trained knowledge to understand and respond to queries in a contextually relevant manner. |
| multifaceted | /ˌmʌltiˈfæsɪtɪd/ | adj. | having many different aspects or features | 多方面的 | ChatGPT is a promising tool for a wide range of diverse and multifaceted applications in consumer health [23]. |
| elucidate | /ɪˈluːsɪdeɪt/ | v. | to explain something clearly | 阐明、解释清楚 | ChatGPT can aid medical research by generating human-like text, offering fundamental guidance, and elucidating complex concepts [1]. ... |
| streamline | /ˈstriːmlaɪn/ | v. | to make a process simpler and more efficient | 精简、优化（流程） | In clinical practice, ChatGPT has the potential to streamline clinical documentation, patient communication, and decision support tasks, thus improving the workflow efficiency. |
| workflow | /ˈwɜːkfləʊ/ | n. | the sequence of tasks that a job involves | 工作流程 | In clinical practice, ChatGPT has the potential to streamline clinical documentation, patient communication, and decision support tasks, thus improving the workflow efficiency. |
| diagnostic | /ˌdaɪəɡˈnɒstɪk/ | adj. | used for identifying a disease or problem | 诊断的 | ChatGPT holds promise in diagnostic assistance and decision support. ... |
| interpretation | /ɪnˌtɜːprɪˈteɪʃn/ | n. | the act of explaining the meaning of information | 解读、判读 | ChatGPT can assist in image interpretation, differential diagnosis, and treatment planning, potentially improving diagnostic accuracy and patient outcomes [21]. ... |
| dermatological | /ˌdɜːmətəˈlɒdʒɪkl/ | adj. | relating to the skin and its diseases | 皮肤科的 | It can offer second opinions on dermatological treatments, which may become increasingly reliable as it continues to optimize [33]. ... |
| reliable | /rɪˈlaɪəbl/ | adj. | able to be trusted to be correct or to work well | 可靠的 | It can offer second opinions on dermatological treatments, which may become increasingly reliable as it continues to optimize [33]. ... |
| algorithmic bias | /ˌælɡəˈrɪðmɪk ˈbaɪəs/ | n. | unfair systematic error produced by an algorithm | 算法偏见 | Addressing risks associated with ethical concerns regarding patient privacy, data security, and algorithmic bias is crucial for ensuring its safe and responsible use. |
| trustworthiness | /ˈtrʌstwɜːðinəs/ | n. | the quality of being able to be relied on | 可信度 | Verifying the accuracy, reliability, and trustworthiness of ChatGPT-generated content requires further investigation [34]. ... |
| imperative | /ɪmˈperətɪv/ | adj. | extremely important and urgent | 极为必要的 | Given these considerations, conducting an umbrella review of systematic reviews on ChatGPT in consumer health is imperative. |
| synthesise | /ˈsɪnθəsaɪz/ | v. | to combine separate pieces of information into a whole | 综合、整合 | This review aims to synthesise research findings to consolidate the implications of ChatGPT integration in healthcare and identify research gaps. ... |
| heterogeneity | /ˌhetərədʒəˈneɪəti/ | n. | the quality of being very different from each other | 异质性、差异性 | Due to the heterogeneity of the included studies, no quantitative analysis was performed. |
| narrative | /ˈnærətɪv/ | adj. | presented as a description rather than as numbers | 叙述式的 | Information was extracted, summarised, synthesised, and presented in a narrative form. ... |
| consolidate | /kənˈsɒlɪdeɪt/ | v. | to bring together and strengthen into one whole | 汇总、巩固 | This review aims to synthesise research findings to consolidate the implications of ChatGPT integration in healthcare and identify research gaps. ... |
| comprehensive | /ˌkɒmprɪˈhensɪv/ | adj. | including everything relevant; complete | 全面的 | To capture a wide-ranging collection of reviews covering ChatGPT's role in consumer health, we performed a comprehensive searching strategy across the database by using a combination of keywords and Boolean operators. |

### 高频搭配与短语动词

| 搭配 | 中文 | 例句 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| offer the potential to | 有……的潜力 | AI-powered tools and technologies offer the potential to revolutionise healthcare delivery, improving patient outcomes, and enhancing clinical decision-making processes. |
| serve as | 充当、作为 | ChatGPT can serve as a valuable resource for medical students, healthcare professionals, and educators [25]. |
| assist in | 协助做…… | It can assist in the creation of educational materials, answer clinical queries, and facilitate interactive learning experiences. |
| hold promise in | 在……方面有前景 | Moreover, ChatGPT holds promise in diagnostic assistance and decision support. |
| enable sb to do | 使某人能够做…… | Its ability to process and analyze medical data, including patient histories, symptoms, and diagnostic tests, enables it to provide valuable insights and recommendations to healthcare providers. |
| pose risks | 带来风险 | Despite its potential benefits, integrating ChatGPT into healthcare practice poses risks, challenges and limitations. |
| translate promises into reality | 把承诺变为现实 | Translating promises into reality is always a significant step. |
| be ideal for | 非常适合 | Thus, it is ideal for exploring ChatGPT’s applications and impacts in healthcare. |
| be conducted according to | 依据……进行 | This umbrella review was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis Protocols guidelines (PRISMA) [26]. |
| be followed by | 随后是、接着进行 | For Google Scholar, specific filters for 'review articles' and sorting by relevance were applied, followed by a targeted search query to refine the results further. |

## 三、长难句解析

> [!example] 长难句 1
> **原句**：Its ability to process and analyze medical data, including patient histories, symptoms, and diagnostic tests, enables it to provide valuable insights and recommendations to healthcare providers. In fields such as radiology and pathology, ChatGPT can assist in image interpretation, differential diagnosis, and treatment planning, potentially improving diagnostic accuracy and patient outcomes [21].
> **结构拆解**：第一句主干是 Its ability enables it to provide valuable insights and recommendations，属于 enable sb to do sth 结构；主语 ability 后接不定式 to process and analyze medical data 作后置定语，说明"能力"的具体内容，两个逗号之间的 including patient histories, symptoms, and diagnostic tests 是插入语，对 medical data 举例补充；句首 Its 指代上一句的 ChatGPT。第二句主干是 ChatGPT can assist in image interpretation, differential diagnosis, and treatment planning；In fields such as radiology and pathology 是介词短语作状语，交代适用领域，can assist in 后接三个并列的名词短语作宾语；句末 potentially improving diagnostic accuracy and patient outcomes [21] 是现在分词短语作结果状语，说明辅助判读可能带来的结果，方括号里的 [21] 是原文的文献编号。
> **参考翻译**：它处理和分析医疗数据（包括病史、症状和诊断检查）的能力，使它能够为医护人员提供有价值的见解和建议。在放射科、病理科这样的领域，ChatGPT 可以协助判读图像、做鉴别诊断和制定治疗方案，从而有可能提高诊断准确率、改善患者预后。

> [!example] 长难句 2
> **原句**：To capture a wide-ranging collection of reviews covering ChatGPT’s role in consumer health, we performed a comprehensive searching strategy across the database by using a combination of keywords and Boolean operators.
> **结构拆解**：句首 To capture... 是不定式短语作目的状语，其中 covering ChatGPT’s role in consumer health 是现在分词短语作后置定语，修饰 reviews。主句主干为 we performed a strategy；across the database 是地点状语；by using a combination of keywords and Boolean operators 是方式状语，by + 动名词表示"通过做某事"。全句体现学术写作常见的"目的—手段—动作"三层信息排列。
> **参考翻译**：为了尽可能广泛地收集涉及 ChatGPT 在消费者健康中作用的综述，我们通过组合关键词与布尔运算符，在数据库中执行了一套全面的检索策略。

> [!example] 长难句 3
> **原句**：Furthermore, deficiencies were observed in reporting the sources of funding (item number 10), addressing the risk of bias when discussing results (item number 13), and explaining or discussing observed heterogeneity (item number 14), indicating areas needing improvement in future reviews.
> **结构拆解**：主句是被动语态 deficiencies were observed，主语 deficiencies（缺陷）被后置，in + 三个并列动名词短语说明缺陷具体出现在哪些环节：reporting the sources of funding、addressing the risk of bias、explaining or discussing observed heterogeneity。when discussing results 是时间状语从句的省略形式（when they discuss results）。句末 indicating... 是现在分词短语作结果状语，needing improvement 又是现在分词短语作后置定语修饰 areas。
> **参考翻译**：此外，在报告资金来源（第 10 项）、讨论结果时处理偏倚风险（第 13 项）以及解释或讨论所观察到的异质性（第 14 项）等方面都发现了不足，这说明未来的综述仍有改进空间。

## 四、专业词汇标注

> [!important] 专业词汇
> 这些词只需"认识"，不必会拼写。

| 专业词汇 | 中文解释 | 所属领域 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Large Language Model (LLM) | 大语言模型，在超大规模文本上预训练的生成模型 | 人工智能 |
| ChatGPT | OpenAI 开发的对话式大语言模型 | 人工智能 |
| Natural Language Processing (NLP) | 自然语言处理 | 计算机科学 |
| transformer architecture | Transformer 架构，当前大语言模型的基础结构 | 深度学习 |
| consumer health | 消费者健康：面向普通人的健康信息与服务 | 公共卫生 |
| umbrella review | 伞形综述：把多篇系统综述再汇总一次的证据综合方法 | 循证医学 |
| systematic review / meta-analysis | 系统综述／荟萃分析 | 循证医学 |
| PRISMA | 系统综述与荟萃分析的报告规范 | 循证医学 |
| AMSTAR-2 | 评价系统综述方法学质量的工具清单 | 循证医学 |
| differential diagnosis | 鉴别诊断：在多种可能疾病中逐一排除 | 临床医学 |
| radiology / pathology | 放射科／病理科 | 临床医学 |
| algorithmic bias | 算法偏见：模型因训练数据或设计产生的系统性不公平 | 人工智能伦理 |

## 五、阅读训练建议

- [ ] 第一遍：不看注释通读全文，记录用时 ___ 分钟
- [ ] 第二遍：查生词表，回读卡住的句子
- [ ] 第三遍：只看英文，口头复述每段大意
- [ ] 输出：用 5 句英文写出本文摘要

> [!tip] 关联阅读
> - [[01-02-人工智能风险管理框架]] —— 本文提到的隐私、偏见、问责问题，正是 NIST 框架要求机构逐项"映射—度量"的对象。
> - [[01-03-人工智能规模扩张之路]] —— 大语言模型的"能力突跳"从何而来：数据、参数与算力三条曲线。
> - [[01-01-算法单一化对招聘的影响]] —— 换一个场景看同一个问题：算法替人做决定时，谁被排除、谁被优待。

## 六、来源与版权说明

- 原文标题：Impact of large language model (ChatGPT) in healthcare: an umbrella review and evidence synthesis
- 来源：Journal of Biomedical Science（2025 年 5 月 7 日；PMC 开放获取全文），作者 Usman Iqbal 等
- 原文链接：https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12057020/
- 说明：本篇英文正文为原文节选，摘录自 Abstract、Background、Methods 与 Results 主体（删节处标 `[...]`），仅用于个人英语学习；正文中的方括号数字为原文文献编号，保留原样。版权归原作者与发布机构所有。
